• TOPICS
    • Design
    • Manufacturing
    • Inspection
    • Heat Treating
    • Lubrication
    • Materials
    • The Gear Industry
    • Gears by Type
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Departments
    • Archives
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
  • NEWSLETTER
    • Subscribe
  • VIDEO
    • Gear Technology TV
      • Ask the Expert Live
      • Revolutions
    • Industry Videos
  • BLOGS
  • BUYER'S GUIDE
  • NEWS and EVENTS
    • Product News
    • Industry News
    • Events
  • ADVERTISING
    • Brand Awareness
      • Print: Display Advertising
      • Online: Web Banners & Keyword Banners
      • Online: Native Advertising (Sponsored Content)
      • E-mail: Custom, White Papers & Webinars
      • E-mail: Newsletter Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
    • Response & Lead Generation
      • Online: Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
      • E-mail: Newsletters
      • E-mail: Newsletter Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
      • E-mail: Custom, White Papers & Webinars
      • Online: Buyers Guide
    • Print Advertising
      • Print: Display Advertising
      • Print: MPT Expo Showstoppers
      • Print: Buyers Guide
      • Print: Manufacturing sMart
      • Print: Specifications
      • MPT Expo Show Guide Advertising
    • Online Advertising
      • Online: Web Banners & Keyword Banners
      • Online: Native Advertising (Sponsored Content)
      • Online: Buyers Guide
      • Online: Specifications
    • E-mail Advertising
      • E-mail: E-Newsletters
      • E-mail: Newsletter Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
      • E-mail: AGMA Industry News
      • E-mail: Custom, White Papers & Webinars
      • E-mail: Specifications
    • Special Promotions
      • Print: MPT Expo Showstoppers
      • Print: Buyers Guide
      • Print: Manufacturing sMart
      • MPT Expo Show Guide Advertising
  • CONTACT US
  • AGMA
    • Membership
    • Events
    • Education
    • Emerging Technology
    • AGMA Media
    • Standards
Subscribe
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Home » Blogs » Gear Talk With Chuck » How Reliable is Our Information?

Gear Talk With Chuck
Gear Talk With Chuck RSS FeedRSS

Design / Manufacturing / Inspection / The Gear Industry / Calculation / Gear Rating / Reliability / Processes / Grinding / Testing / Traceability / AGMA / Standards / AGMA 2001
Charles schultz
Chuck Schultz is a licensed engineer, Gear Technology Technical Editor, and Chief Engineer for Beyta Gear Service. He has written the "Gear Talk with Chuck" blog for Gear Technology since 2014.

How Reliable is Our Information?

September 22, 2015
Charles D. Schultz
No Comments
How much can we trust our understanding of how things work? There was a special joint web ex meeting this week between two AGMA committees that got me thinking about how we come to accept some methods and, over time, lose sight of how they came to be. The meeting came about because the Wind Turbine committee is working on a new and improved version of ANSI/AGMA/AWEA 6006 and an interpretation was requested from the Helical Gear Rating committee on the use of reliability factors. The Wind Turbine community has been putting a lot of resources into improving turbine reliability and is ready to greatly modernize and expand the calculation of system reliability estimates. The reliability factors in AGMA 2001 modify capacity based upon the designer’s tolerance for failure. If 1-failure-in-10 can be tolerated, for example, the gearset can transmit more power than if only 1-failure-in-a-1,000 is acceptable; the default setting is 1-failure-in-100. In response to the inquiry, the helical gear rating committee checked their records and traced the chart to a 1979 meeting. According to the minutes of that meeting, the data was the result of metallurgical testing by the United States Navy. Further digging turned up some computer printouts of the tests — but no narrative of the experiment’s design or execution. This printout will now be used by the Wind Turbine’s experts to review the type of distribution that will be employed to improve the reliability calculation. An effort will be made to locate more information on the test itself so that future committee members will have a better basis upon which to build. This situation calls to mind an earlier flap over the widely used rim thickness factor. In working on the new helical gear rating standard we discovered that various product standards had different rim thickness factors, but all referred to the same Fall Technical Meeting paper from many years ago. When that paper was pulled out and studied, it was found that no one was properly applying it as it concerned a planet gear with a bearing mounted in it — not a webbed gear, as everyone erroneously recalled. The lesson I took away was that we need more traceability in the standards. No one wants to wade through hundreds of pages of footnotes in a standard, but there ought to be an annotated copy somewhere that links each piece of data or formula to its source material.    

Recent Comments

Thank you for this - Happy Saint Patrick's...

Post a comment to this article

Report Abusive Comment

Free Gear Technology Subscriptions
Subscribe
Free Gear Technology Subscriptions
Subscribe
FEATURED VIDEO
  • Kapp3
    Kapp Niles ZP 20 Set-up
December 15, 2022
RECOMMENDED
  • Precision Equals Performance at ZPE GripTec

    October 12, 2022
    gt0922_Page_28_Image_0003.jpg
  • State of the Powder Metal Industry

    October 12, 2022
    gt0922_Page_30_Image_0001.jpg
  • The Afterglow of Furnaces North America 2022

    October 12, 2022
    gt0922_Page_20_Image_0001.jpg
  • Reigniting the Educational Infrastructure

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122_Page_20_Image_0001.jpg
  • Profile: Continuing Education and Training with the AGMA

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122_Page_26_Image_0001.jpg
  • Reigniting the Educational Infrastructure

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122_Page_20_Image_0001.jpg
  • Profile: Continuing Education and Training with the AGMA

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122_Page_26_Image_0001.jpg
  • Precision Equals Performance at ZPE GripTec

    October 12, 2022
    gt0922_Page_28_Image_0003.jpg
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Contribute
  • AGMA
Powered byAGMA
Copyright © 2023 Gear Technology
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact