• TOPICS
    • Design
    • Manufacturing
    • Inspection
    • Heat Treating
    • Lubrication
    • Materials
    • The Gear Industry
    • Gears by Type
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Departments
    • Archives
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
  • NEWSLETTER
    • Subscribe
  • VIDEO
    • Gear Technology TV
      • Ask the Expert Live
      • Revolutions
    • Industry Videos
  • BLOGS
  • BUYER'S GUIDE
  • NEWS and EVENTS
    • Product News
    • Industry News
    • Events
  • ADVERTISING
    • Brand Awareness
      • Print: Display Advertising
      • Online: Web Banners & Keyword Banners
      • Online: Native Advertising (Sponsored Content)
      • E-mail: Custom, White Papers & Webinars
      • E-mail: Newsletter Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
    • Response & Lead Generation
      • Online: Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
      • E-mail: Newsletters
      • E-mail: Newsletter Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
      • E-mail: Custom, White Papers & Webinars
      • Online: Buyers Guide
    • Print Advertising
      • Print: Display Advertising
      • Print: MPT Expo Showstoppers
      • Print: Buyers Guide
      • Print: Manufacturing sMart
      • Print: Specifications
      • MPT Expo Show Guide Advertising
    • Online Advertising
      • Online: Web Banners & Keyword Banners
      • Online: Native Advertising (Sponsored Content)
      • Online: Buyers Guide
      • Online: Specifications
    • E-mail Advertising
      • E-mail: E-Newsletters
      • E-mail: Newsletter Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
      • E-mail: AGMA Industry News
      • E-mail: Custom, White Papers & Webinars
      • E-mail: Specifications
    • Special Promotions
      • Print: MPT Expo Showstoppers
      • Print: Buyers Guide
      • Print: Manufacturing sMart
      • MPT Expo Show Guide Advertising
  • CONTACT US
  • AGMA
    • Membership
    • Events
    • Education
    • Emerging Technology
    • AGMA Media
    • Standards
Subscribe
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Home » Blogs » Gear Talk With Chuck » Bending the Rules

Gear Talk With Chuck
Gear Talk With Chuck RSS FeedRSS

Design / The Gear Industry / Calculation / Bearings / Software / Strength / Economy
Charles schultz
Chuck Schultz is a licensed engineer, Gear Technology Technical Editor, and Chief Engineer for Beyta Gear Service. He has written the "Gear Talk with Chuck" blog for Gear Technology since 2014.

Bending the Rules

May 1, 2018
Charles D. Schultz
No Comments
Gears Engineering 1 of 9
In my last posting I advised designers to avoid relying on “rules of thumb” or computer coding when confronted with tough decisions. This admonition has its roots in one of the key moments in my own career as a gearbox designer. A sizeable team was assigned to an emergency upgrade of a product line that was not faring well in the marketplace. It was the company’s first foray into surface hardened gearing and the idea of using a ground carburized and hardened pinion with an unground induction hardened gear did not pan out. More gear grinders were on the boat from Europe and the revolving elements had to be improved and tested before they were put into service. Other internal changes, such as a shift from ball bearings to taper roller bearings, were also needed, so new “study layouts” and calculations were required. Marketing weighed in with specific horsepower capacity goals for each ratio of each size. There were twelve sizes with 36 ratio combinations in each size. Four of those units were my portion of the work load. Computer time was a limiting resource. I had thirty-six sizeable boxes of “punch cards” that I personally typed out as input to the main frame computer. Each night our “problem sets” would be messengered to the computer room at the main plant and run through the IBM 370 overnight. A single bent, damaged, or misplaced card would void the run and delay your report. Our messenger was notorious for dropping boxes of cards and stuffing them back in without telling anyone — so every designer was diligent about marking and securing their cards for reshuffling. Our team was having a terrible time meeting the goals marketing set for us. One day, however, a set I was struggling with miraculously healed itself and made the capacity target. I had retyped an input card to replace one damaged in a transport mishap; a careful check on it revealed that I had transposed a couple digits on the pinion outside diameter. This larger diameter, although violating the “old family recipe,” did not set off any warning messages and the strength capacity increased enough to meet the goal. My supervisor chewed me out for sloppy typing but did not specifically forbid me from investigating the beneficial effects further. I soon had all of my “problem ratios” meeting the marketing targets and proudly reported this at the team meeting. My reward was a private interrogation by the department supervisor and the gear software writers. It was an uncomfortable couple of hours, but it resulted in a revision to the old family recipe to include a “strength balancing routine.” An average designer respects boundaries. A great designer moves the boundaries. Aim for greatness.

Recent Comments

Thank you for this - Happy Saint Patrick's...

Post a comment to this article

Report Abusive Comment

Free Gear Technology Subscriptions
Subscribe
Free Gear Technology Subscriptions
Subscribe
FEATURED VIDEO
  • Marposs
    Marposs OptoCloud EDU
December 15, 2022
RECOMMENDED
  • Precision Equals Performance at ZPE GripTec

    October 12, 2022
    gt0922_Page_28_Image_0003.jpg
  • State of the Powder Metal Industry

    October 12, 2022
    gt0922_Page_30_Image_0001.jpg
  • The Afterglow of Furnaces North America 2022

    October 12, 2022
    gt0922_Page_20_Image_0001.jpg
  • Reigniting the Educational Infrastructure

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122_Page_20_Image_0001.jpg
  • Profile: Continuing Education and Training with the AGMA

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122_Page_26_Image_0001.jpg
  • Reigniting the Educational Infrastructure

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122_Page_20_Image_0001.jpg
  • Profile: Continuing Education and Training with the AGMA

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122_Page_26_Image_0001.jpg
  • Precision Equals Performance at ZPE GripTec

    October 12, 2022
    gt0922_Page_28_Image_0003.jpg
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Contribute
  • AGMA
Powered byAGMA
Copyright © 2023 Gear Technology
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact