Gears are wonderful things. Unfortunately, they require support from shafts, bearings, and some sort of housing to be useful.
Before we move on from helix angle restrictions, I want to say a few things about face contact ratio.
Some of you are probably calling forth the gear deities to smite me for promoting a “free thinking” approach to helix angles; I understand completely. As with the mispronunciation of “helical,” tolerance is not just a technical term to argue about at a non-conforming material review.
Regular followers of this blog know whenever I say “it all depends,” that I am compelled to credit industry legend Ray Drago for stealing his catchphrase.
We left the gear tribe arguing over how to solve the problems that were cropping up with the new-fangled double helical or herringbone designs.
When we cannot even agree how to pronounce “helical” it should not be a surprise that there is so much confusion about “proper” limits on helix angles.