Robert E. Smith
Wait a minute, we don’t measure pitch diameter. We’re sometimes asked to measure it by customers, though, especially ones with older drawings or with gear orders outsourced by them. But measuring pitch diameter is a fallacy.
When a gear inspector takes a gage and uses its anvils or pins on diametrically opposed tooth spaces, what he’s actually measuring is changes in tooth thickness.
Pitch diameter is the diameter of a pitch circle. The standard (reference) pitch circle is defined as: "The circle which intersects the involute at the point where the pressure angle is equal to the profile angle of the basic rack." The standard pitch diameter, D, is the diameter of this standard (reference) pitch circle and is obtained by D = N/Pd or--in the metric system--by D = Nm, where N is the number of teeth, Pd is the standard transverse diametral pitch, and m is the module. See the American Gear Manufacturers Association standard ANSI/AGMA 1012-F90, Gear Nomenclature Terms, Definitions, Symbols, and Abbreviations.
Therefore, the standard pitch diameter is actually a reference dimension that doesn’t change as long as the number of teeth and the diametral pitch or module don’t change. The standard pitch diameter shouldn’t have a tolerance and isn’t measured.
When manufacturing a gear, the cutting or grinding tool may be fed in or out to make a size change. What this actually does is make the teeth thicker or thinner, at the standard pitch circle (gear reference circle). The standard pitch diameter, however, doesn’t change. See Figure 1, which appears as Figure B.1 in AGMA 913-A98, Method for Specifying the Measuring Geometry of Spur and Helical Gears. The right and left halves of this drawing show the relative position of the cutting tool and the resulting change in tooth thickness. Note that the standard pitch circle (gear reference circle) doesn’t change.
Figure 1--Hypothetical tool with zero backlash and finished gear. (Extracted from AGMA 913-A98 with AGMA permission.)
When measuring thickness change, it’s common practice to measure the gear over pins or anvils. This is often called a measurement over wires (MOW). As the teeth get thinner, this measurement becomes smaller. Figure 2 shows an MOW operation. This illustration appears as Figure 6-1 in ANSI/AGMA 2002-B88, Tooth Thickness Specification and Measurement. Note that the caption says "Tooth thickness measurement over pins," not "Pitch diameter measurement." This is actually a diameter measurement (not pitch diameter) that has been calculated from the tooth thickness at the standard pitch diameter.
Figure 2--Tooth thickness measurement over pins. (Extracted from AGMA 2002-B88 with AGMA permission.)
It is highly recommended that specifiers of gear data and tolerances refer to the above AGMA standards and information sheets, as well as association documents on subjects such as gear accuracy. These are available from the AGMA, in Alexandria, VA, or through www.agma.org.
For more information:
500 Montgomery Street, Suite 350
Alexandria, VA 22314-1581
Phone: (703) 684-0211
Fax: (703) 684-0242
Robert E. Smith
R.E. Smith & Co. Inc.
3085 Mt. Read Blvd.
Rochester, NY 14616
Phone: (585) 621-2838
Fax: (585) 663-2641
Robert E. Smith is president of R.E. Smith & Co. Inc., a gear consultancy in Rochester, NY. A mechanical engineer, he has more than 55 years’ experience in the gear industry. He chairs the AGMA Calibration Committee and is the ISO delegate for it and for the AGMA Inspection and Handbook Committee. Also, since 1991, he’s been a Gear Technology technical editor.