• TOPICS
    • Design
    • Manufacturing
    • Inspection
    • Heat Treating
    • Lubrication
    • Materials
    • The Gear Industry
    • Gears by Type
  • MAGAZINE
    • Current Issue
    • Departments
    • Archives
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
  • NEWSLETTER
    • Subscribe
  • VIDEO
    • Gear Technology TV
      • Ask the Expert Live
      • Revolutions
    • Industry Videos
  • BLOGS
  • BUYER'S GUIDE
  • NEWS and EVENTS
    • Product News
    • Industry News
    • Events
  • ADVERTISING
    • Brand Awareness
      • Print: Display Advertising
      • Online: Web Banners & Keyword Banners
      • Online: Native Advertising (Sponsored Content)
      • E-mail: Custom, White Papers & Webinars
      • E-mail: Newsletter Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
    • Response & Lead Generation
      • Online: Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
      • E-mail: Newsletters
      • E-mail: Newsletter Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
      • E-mail: Custom, White Papers & Webinars
      • Online: Buyers Guide
    • Print Advertising
      • Print: Display Advertising
      • Print: MPT Expo Showstoppers
      • Print: Buyers Guide
      • Print: Manufacturing sMart
      • Print: Specifications
      • MPT Expo Show Guide Advertising
    • Online Advertising
      • Online: Web Banners & Keyword Banners
      • Online: Native Advertising (Sponsored Content)
      • Online: Buyers Guide
      • Online: Specifications
    • E-mail Advertising
      • E-mail: E-Newsletters
      • E-mail: Newsletter Sponsored Content (Native Advertising)
      • E-mail: AGMA Industry News
      • E-mail: Custom, White Papers & Webinars
      • E-mail: Specifications
    • Special Promotions
      • Print: MPT Expo Showstoppers
      • Print: Buyers Guide
      • Print: Manufacturing sMart
      • MPT Expo Show Guide Advertising
  • CONTACT US
  • AGMA
    • Membership
    • Events
    • Education
    • Emerging Technology
    • AGMA Media
    • Standards
Subscribe
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Home » Blogs » Gear Talk With Chuck » Moderation Instead of Modification

Gear Talk With Chuck
Gear Talk With Chuck RSS FeedRSS

Design / Materials / The Gear Industry / Center Distance / Contact Ratio / Optimization / Software / Micropitting / Pitting / Standards / Pinions
Charles schultz
Chuck Schultz is a licensed engineer, Gear Technology Technical Editor, and Chief Engineer for Beyta Gear Service. He has written the "Gear Talk with Chuck" blog for Gear Technology since 2014.

Moderation Instead of Modification

April 12, 2018
Charles D. Schultz
No Comments
Few designers would feel comfortable with a face to pinion pitch diameter ratio of 2.00 anymore. Some still prefer to select face width by face contact ratios, often aiming for integral values. When designing a product with a range of gear ratios, I have found it best to use a .3 to .4 limit instead of .5 on the face to center distance ratio. This keeps the face to pitch diameter ratio comfortably low for ratios less than 5.50:1. We used to routinely use single stages with up to 7.6:1 ratios. Eventually we came to understand that just because something was allowed by a rating standard did not mean it was a good idea. Very seldom do the extremes of a formula result in outstanding field performance. Limiting ratios to 3.5 to 5:1 with a .3 to .4 face to center distance ratio results in face width to pitch diameter ratios that are in the 1.00 to 1.25 range. These “short, stubby” pinions tend to be very robust. By robust we mean resistant to both torsional and bending deflection. Robust gear sets do not need lots of “optimization” and tolerate a range of loading conditions very well. A competitor’s salesman once told a customer that my new product line was obviously imported from Europe because it had metric center distances and those short stubby pinions. So unlike his legacy designs with “inch” centers and wider face widths. I was not offended by his gossip but wrote a memo for my salesman to give to the customer describing the design process that lead us to the “same” conclusion as our European competitors. The rating formulas work the same in Pittsburgh as they do in Munich. Computer modeling allows the designer to test a wide variety of proportions before committing to a specific layout. Wonderful technology is available in every personal computer so you do not need to take my word for what works best for your application. Just be careful about designing yourself into a corner by using the extremes of the standard’s formulas.

Recent Comments

Thank you for this - Happy Saint Patrick's...

Post a comment to this article

Report Abusive Comment

Free Gear Technology Subscriptions
Subscribe
Free Gear Technology Subscriptions
Subscribe
FEATURED VIDEO
  • Marposs
    Marposs OptoCloud EDU
December 15, 2022
RECOMMENDED
  • 2022 Gear Technology Buyer's Guide

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122-buyers-guide.jpg
  • Reigniting the Educational Infrastructure

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122_Page_20_Image_0001.jpg
  • Profile: Continuing Education and Training with the AGMA

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122_Page_26_Image_0001.jpg
  • Polished Up!

    February 13, 2023
    gt0123_Page_38_Image_0002.jpg
  • Remaining Competitive

    February 13, 2023
    gt0123_Page_42_Image_0001.jpg
  • Polished Up!

    February 13, 2023
    gt0123_Page_38_Image_0002.jpg
  • Remaining Competitive

    February 13, 2023
    gt0123_Page_42_Image_0001.jpg
  • 2022 Gear Technology Buyer's Guide

    December 5, 2022
    gt1122-buyers-guide.jpg
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Contribute
  • AGMA
Powered byAGMA
Copyright © 2023 Gear Technology
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact